Tuesday, February 9th, 2010

Professors making profits upsets students, ASG, and Pres. Foster

Posted on April 1, 2009 @ 11:02 am

Textbook prices are always a hot issue for students and faculty alike, but now a new issue has arisen, coming to the attention of Associated Student Government.

ASG is currently looking at the issue of professors mandating students to buy their own textbooks they themselves have written for their classes, in turn making a profit.

The main book that is fueling this debate is the book written by professor Steve Murray required for Health and Wellness. The format of the class requires that students buy the textbook and turn in pages torn out of the back of the book rather than photocopying them. It is even required for students taking the online class to turn in the worksheets in the back of the book.

This issue first came to ASG’s attention after getting complaints and hearing students talk about not being able to sell the book back.

“We felt that it was in our realm of responsibility to take this on,” ASG Senate Leader Nick Lopez said. “We’re still doing internal research but we’re going to continue to pursue it.”

According to ASG Vice President Ryan Hendershot, one of the options they are looking at is going to professors in different departments and gathering signatures to gain support for this issue and changing the handbook to state that professors cannot gain profit from their books sold. Another option is donating the money to the school or to their specific department. The problem then, according to Hendershot, is that the professor is still indirectly benefiting from the sale of their book.

“It’s a question of a conflict of interest,” Hendershot said.
Mesa State President Tim Foster believes that there are good sides to each argument and an action is hard to define.

“It’s a fine line,” Foster said. “We have people that are talented and are able to write text books so we wouldn’t want to deprive students the right to use the books.”

1 Comment »

  1. Point 1: Why is it inconceivable that Professor X requires his (or her) students to purchase a textbook he (or she) wrote because the book contains the information Professor X wants them to know? At MSC, why do the ASG, students, and President Foster automatically assume such a situation results from Professor X’s greed? Why are students willing to purchase Professor Y’s book for Professor X’s class without assuming that Professor Y is greedy? Don’t assume that Professor X will get rich from MSC’s small population of students. Point 2: Why is Professor X wrong in wanting to protect his (etc.) intellectual property if other authors, composers, etc., have the legal right to do so? Xeroxing text for personal use is theft, just as copying tapes, CDs, and DVDs is theft. MSC’s students are neither special nor exempt from copyright laws. Enrollment as a college student does not give any person license to steal.

    Comment by AndreA — April 3, 2009 @ 1:24 pm

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URL

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.

© Copyright Mesa State College Criterion
Proudly hosted by GJSentinel.com

GJSentinel button